创意与媒体Reddit 原帖

Is this a legit source to obtain a Silicone Version of the Avidemux App?

完整上下文原始内容 · Reddit

Avidemux is my primary choice when for quick video editing (cutting of joining video files), because it does not recode the whole output-file again. However, the official version / source (https://avidemux.sourceforge.net) seems not to be maintained anymore (last version 2021) and it's an Intel based app, which will no longer work in a future version of MacOS. Recently I stumbled upon this site, which claims to be not affiliated with the original Avidemux project. They offer an updates Silicone-Version of the Avidemux app: https://avidemux.net/download/ Do you guys think that this source is legit and safe to use, or should I rather be careful wilt downloading and installing this software?

01需求标签
创意与媒体缺失功能桌面应用未解决

已收集讨论

14 条已收集

14条已收集14条 Reddit 标称评论
u/MaxGaav

To me, that doesn't look legit. You could check the DMG on the site of VirusTotal (free) Do you know LosslessCut (free)?

u/PaulMuadDib-Usul楼主回复

Yep, I just learned about Lossless Cut. Seems to follow a similar approach. I just wanted to avoid the time-consuming recoding when I just want to cut a file or join two similar files. Does Lossless Cut also support joining video files without recoding (when they have a similar bitrate)?

u/behridingle

Shotcut is open source and has an ARM version: https://www.shotcut.org/

u/PaulMuadDib-Usul楼主回复

I use Shotcut sometimes, too, for more complex tasks. But AFAIK it does not offer the simple “copy” function of Avidemux. With Shotcut, like with many other Video editing tools, you always have to do a new encoding for the output file - unless I am missing / misunderstanding something in Shotcut.

u/xMatias_LAS

If after installation you get a message that the app is broken, it is because it is not notorized by Apple. With notorization in place, it might be legit.

u/PaulMuadDib-Usul楼主回复

There is no installation file available. See my edit above.

u/PushPlus9069

For your specific need — cut/join without re-encoding — the tool you actually want is LosslessCut (someone mentioned it above). Native Apple Silicon, still maintained, free, and it does exactly the stream-copy trim/join Avidemux does, no quality loss. For that workflow it's honestly a better fit than Avidemux, so I'd jump straight to it instead of chasing an unofficial build. One caution on the Shotcut suggestion: great editor, but for simple cuts it re-encodes on export by default, so you'd lose the "no recode" benefit that's the whole reason you use Avidemux. Different tool for a different job. On the third-party site: for a GPL app, an "updated" binary from someone with no public source repo is exactly the thing to be wary of — they legally could publish the source so people can build and verify it, and not doing so is a flag. If you ever really needed to, VirusTotal plus checking it's Apple-notarized (like others said) is the minimum, but for cut/join you don't need to take that risk at all. And FWIW the old Intel Avidemux still runs under Rosetta 2 on Apple Silicon today, so you've got a working bridge while you switch over — no rush to grab a sketchy build.

u/harry-harrison-79

i'd treat that kind of build as untrusted unless you can trace it back to the original maintainer or a very clear fork with source, releases, and reproducible-ish notes. before running it, check the signature first. Terminal can tell you a lot with spctl -a -vv /path/to/app.app and codesign -dv --verbose=4 /path/to/app.app. if it is unsigned, not notarized, or signed by a random name with no public repo/history, i would not use it for media files you care about.

u/dris77

Yeah I'm worried about this too. Avidemux is so light and powerful... I use it all the time to cut up video, then output without re encoding... also use it to quickly change containers, or change the audio. I hope somebody makes a silicon version before it's too late.

u/PaulMuadDib-Usul楼主回复

Right, but does this mean that Apple's security measures still apply or did you just circumvent it by clicking "open anyway". However, there's another level, where Apple would not let you even open the app via context / shortcut menu, but you need to apply Xattr in Terminal. Maybe these are the "unscanned" and "unnotarized" apps, while these ones are just from unregistered developers. Honestly, I do not really understand the difference. Edit: OK, it's probably a scam. I tried to download it and the download link leads you to some kind of filehoster ("terabox") where it says that the file has been deleted...