个人效率Reddit 原帖

alternativa a permanent eraser

完整上下文原始内容 · Reddit

ho sempre utilizzato su Mac permane eraser, ma ultimamente esce il popup che dai prossimi aggiornamenti di Mac OS non sarà più utilizzabile ne avviabile. chiedevo se esiste un alternativa valida per la cancellazione sicura dei file richiamabile tramite menu contestuale (per intenderci tasto destro del mouse), grazie

01需求标签
个人效率产品替代桌面应用候选方案待验证

已收集讨论

8 条已收集

8条已收集11条 Reddit 标称评论
u/Ok-Rest-5321

It must be an intel app https://alternativeto.net/software/permanent-eraser/?platform=mac You may find soemthing here Translation : I've always used Permanent Eraser on my Mac, but recently I've been getting a popup saying it won't be usable or launchable with future Mac OS updates. I was wondering if there's a viable alternative for securely deleting files that can be accessed via the context menu (i.e., right-click). Thanks.

u/FoxOnTheRunNow回复

would you pay for such app? a small amount for lifetime access/ I have been thinking about building one

u/Ok-Rest-5321回复

Never heard of this app until now but whats wrong with cmd+backspace on a file to move it to the trahs?

u/MaxGaav

You mean something like this? I bought it a couple of years ago through Bundlehunt, but I actually never used it so far. So I can't tell you if it's worth buying at full price.

u/WhiteMinds

I would be careful with any app that promises true per-file secure erase on modern Macs. With SSD wear leveling, APFS snapshots, backups, and temporary copies, overwriting one file in place is not as reliable as it used to be on old spinning disks. If the goal is privacy, the strongest practical setup is FileVault enabled before sensitive data is stored, plus a full erase/reinstall when handing off the machine. For a right-click convenience workflow, a Finder Quick Action can delete selected files, but I would treat that as convenience rather than a real forensic guarantee.

u/HelloFovea

You can actually replace it with a Quick Action in Automator — no third-party app needed. Set it to receive files or folders in Finder, add a Run Shell Script action with "as arguments", and pass rm -rfP. Save it, and it'll show up in your right-click menu under Quick Actions. The -P flag does the same three-pass overwrite Permanent Eraser was doing. If you'd rather not mess with Automator, TrashMe 3 has secure delete with right-click integration and is still actively maintained. One thing worth mentioning: on Apple Silicon with FileVault on, multi-pass secure overwrite isn't really doing what you think anymore. The SSD controller decides where bits physically land, not the OS. With FileVault, just deleting and emptying Trash is already cryptographically safe. But I get that the right-click workflow is satisfying — the Quick Action gives you that without relying on a deprecated app.